Mercedes-Benz is considering ending a suit that claims a Chinese-made car, that is set to go on sale in Europe in mid-January, looks too much like its Smart ForTwo. According to Automotive News Europe, the Shuanghuan Bubble could go on sale later this month as lawyers from Mercedes-Benz and the Chinese car’s Italian importer Martin Motors come close to settling legal actions that have blocked the sale of the minicar.

The battle between Mercedes-Benz and Martin Motors began just before the launch of the IAA in Frankfurt in Sept. 2007. At the time Mercedes-Benz had obtained court orders banning the sale of the Bubble minicar in Germany claiming the car infringed its copyright for the Smart ForTwo. A month later, Martin Motors launched a counter-suit against Mercedes-Benz seeking damages of more than  €100 million ($135 million USD) as compensation for lost Bubble sales.

But now, Mercedes-Benz fears that it could lose the case in Court and could be forced to pay damages. Just last month, a court in Milan rejected BMW’s claim that the Shuanghuan CEO, which is also distributed by Martin Motors, is a clone of the BMW X5. Sources say that the ruling against BMW has pushed Mercedes-Benz lawyers to be a little more careful.

Currently, German customs is holding one unit of the Bubble that was confiscated before its Frankfurt Motor Show debut in 2007. Italian authorities are holding up six Bubbles, one of which was supposed to be shown at the Bologna Motor Show.

Related Posts:

  1. Miscellaneous Thoughts: Rolls-Royce considers lawsuit over Phantom clone, secret to saving Chrysler found
  2. Smart fits 13 people into a Smart ForTwo
  3. Smart U.S. President: No room for hanky-panky in the Smart ForTwo
  4. Smart ForTwo goes on sale in January 2008 for $11,590
  5. Mercedes may sue over Chinese Smart copycat

  • ecandlcubed
    Wuss. I sue the pants of the Chinese for intellectual right infringement. Or maybe the Chinese owns Germany like they do with the Americans. How do I say "Bend over please" in Manderin?
  • zermatt
    What is with the Italian courts that they see no problem with the blatant design theft?

    Consumer electronics, clothing, automobiles....

    Is there an original thought in China?
  • pat
    Wow...these guys just keep copying the Germans left and right and the Germans can't do anything about it. That sucks
  • Kabluey
    Don't worry Mercedes, I wouldn't trust the Chinese with anything more than fireworks---they're cars last year failed miserably in EU crash tests embarrassingly at that...
  • chinese auto fan
    Shuanghuan is rubbish
blog comments powered by Disqus